Top Myths About Insurance—Busted by Experts

Myth: “The cheapest auto insurance is fine — it’s all the same.” Busted. Coverage varies wildly. Liability limits, collision, comprehensive, and uninsured motorist protections matter. A low premium can mean skimpy coverage or high deductibles that leave you paying out of pocket after a crash. Experts recommend matching liability limits to your net worth (to protect assets) and carrying collision/comprehensive when repair costs exceed your deductible plus salvage value. Common mistakes include assuming state minimums are enough and forgetting to update coverage after life changes like buying a home or adding a teen driver.

Myth: “Higher deductibles always save money.” Sometimes true, sometimes risky. A higher deductible reduces premiums because you assume more upfront cost during a claim. But if an accident leaves you unable to afford the deductible, that “savings” becomes a burden. Choose a deductible you could realistically pay tomorrow. For short-term budgeting, keep an emergency fund to cover deductibles; for long-term savings, balance premium reductions against potential out-of-pocket exposure.

Myth: “Liability limits are optional fluff.” Not even close. Liability limits determine how much your insurer will pay for injuries or damage you cause. If you carry minimal limits and cause a serious accident, you could face lawsuits that pierce through your personal finances. Umbrella policies are a cost-effective way to extend liability protection beyond auto and homeowners limits, often starting at $1 million and costing surprisingly little compared to the potential financial fallout of a large claim.

Myth: “Homeowners and renters insurance do the same thing.” Nope. Homeowners insurance covers the structure, personal property, and liability for those who own the home. Renters insurance focuses on personal belongings and liability, but not the building itself—that’s the landlord’s responsibility. Both can include additional living expense coverage if you’re displaced. Tip: Document valuables, store receipts, and update limits after major purchases.

Myth: “Umbrella insurance is only for the wealthy.” Umbrella policies are for anyone who wants a safety net. If you have savings, a mortgage, a small business, or even a large tax refund—your assets are worth protecting. Umbrellas kick in when primary liability policies max out and can cover libel, slander, and certain legal defense costs.

Myth: “Small business insurance isn’t necessary until something bad happens.” Wrong — proactive coverage and risk management save money and reputation. Small businesses should consider general liability, professional liability (errors & omissions), commercial property, and workers’ compensation where applicable. Many industries need specialized coverages—cyber liability for online operations, product liability for makers, and business interruption to replace lost income after a disaster.

Mistakes small business owners make include underinsuring inventory, ignoring contract-required limits, and not separating personal vs. business liabilities. Risk management strategies—safety training, contract reviews, cybersecurity protocols—reduce both premiums and claim likelihood.

Insurance can feel opaque, but the answer isn’t “buy the cheapest policy” or “skip umbrella.” It’s about matching coverage to risk, understanding deductibles and liability limits, and layering protections sensibly. Talk to an agent, get multiple quotes, and revisit policies after big life or business changes. A little planning today prevents a financial crisis tomorrow.